(02) 4924 5400
mail@advitechgroup.com.au
(02) 4924 5400
Facebook
LinkedIn
    MENUMENU
    • Home
    • Services
            • STEM-Based Consulting
            • Engineering Consulting
            • Asset Integrity and Reliability
            • Environment
            • National Pollutant Inventory Reporting
            • Functional Safety and Risk
            • Project Delivery
            • Process Safety
            • Simulation and Modelling
            • Energy and Sustainability
            • Energy Efficiency
            • Resource Optimisation
            • Carbon Management
            • Smart Systems
            • Sensor Networks
            • Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT)
            • Communication Networks
            • Intercepta Smart Radar Camera
            • Advanced Manufacturing
            • Advanced Manufacturing
            • Integrated Noise Management
            • Noise Monitoring Data
            • AI Noise Mgmt
            • Data Intelligence
            • Noise Control Solutions
            • Operational Noise Control
            • Noise Mgmt Life Cycle
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Engineering Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Environment Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Project Delivery Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Safety and Risk Management Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Novecom about your

            Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) Needs

            +61 2 4924 5460
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Resource Optimisation Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Novecom about your

            Intercepta Smart Radar Camera Needs

            +61 2 4924 5460
          • Contact Acubis Technologies about your

            Wireless Networks Needs

            +61 1300 660 676
          • Contact Novecom about your

            Sensor Networks Needs

            +61 2 4924 5460
          • Contact Simulation Modelling Services about your

            Simulation and Modelling Needs

            +61 2 4926 1500
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Carbon Management Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Energy Efficiency Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Advanced Manufacturing Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Novecom about your

            Noise Monitoring Data Needs

            +61 2 4924 5460
          • Contact Advitech about your

            AI Noise Mgmt Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Data Intelligence Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Hushpak Engineering about your

            Noise Control Solutions Needs

            +61 2 4964 4000
          • operational noise control

            Contact Advitech about your

            Operational Noise Control Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
          • Contact Advitech about your

            Noise Mgmt Life Cycle Needs

            +61 2 4924 5400
    • Services
      • STEM-Based Consulting
        • Environment
        • National Pollutant Inventory Reporting
        • Functional Safety and Risk
        • Process Safety
        • Simulation and Modelling
      • Engineering Consulting
        • Project Delivery
      • Smart Systems
        • Sensor Networks
        • Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT)
        • Communication Networks
        • Intercepta Smart Radar Camera
      • Integrated Noise Management
        • Noise Monitoring Data
        • AI Noise Mgmt
        • Data Intelligence
        • Noise Control Solutions
        • Operational Noise Control
        • Noise Mgmt Life Cycle
      • Energy and Sustainability
        • Energy Efficiency
        • Resource Optimisation
        • Carbon Management
      • Advanced Manufacturing
    • Projects
    • Sectors
      • Mining
      • Coal Preparation and Handling
      • Agriculture
      • Defence
      • Manufacturing
      • Infrastructure
      • Performance Venues
      • Government Agencies
      • Warehouse and Distribution
    • About
      • The Advitech Group
      • Management Team
      • History
      • Working Here
    • Companies
      • Advitech
      • Novecom
      • Hushpak
      • Acubis
      • SMS
    • News
    • Contact

Why design should anticipate human error

July 23, 2018Advitech, Engineering, Mining, Safety and Risk ManagementDianne Hoskins

A tragic accident occurred in a US underground coal mine early in 2018.  Work was being carried out on a conveyor belt without proper isolation and lockout.  The conveyor unexpectedly moved, fatally injuring one of the workers.  Advitech’s Lead Functional Safety Engineer, Mike Taylor read the investigation and was shocked by some of the findings.

The conveyor was provided with so-called “belt switches,” located at 150 m intervals along the belt.  These switches can be used to stop and start the conveyor, consisting as they do of a string of switches in series on a single active electric wire running the length of the conveyor.  If any one of the switches were to be opened, or if a wire were to break, the conveyor would stop and not be able to restart.

The proper place for whole current isolation and lockout was about 400 m away from the worksite, a ten minute journey in a vehicle.  The worker carried personal locks, but did not use them at the designated isolation point, instead relying on a nearby belt switch.

As it happened, shortly after the work started a co-worker accidently bumped one of these switches when driving a vehicle from the surface to the worksite.  The wires broke.  This was a safe failure, because zero current in the wires meant that the conveyor, stationary at the time, could not restart.  The co-worker, well-intentioned but unqualified for the task, reconnected the wires according to their colours.  In doing so he inadvertently short circuited the active and return wires, which meant that switches further inbye, including the one used by the person carrying out the conveyor repairs, no longer had any effect and were all rendered dangerous, that is, the conveyor could start.  In fact the conveyor did start, once the wrong wiring connections were made.

The investigation identified two root causes: failure to follow isolation and lockout procedures, and unqualified persons conducting electrical repairs.  Action was taken to revise the isolation procedures and to retrain people.  Action was also taken to acquaint people with the need to use qualified electricians for electrical work.

Now for few more issues.  Why did the investigation fail to mention shortcomings of the design, the string of belt switches that facilitated or perhaps even encouraged people to avoid a long journey to the correct isolation spot?  Why was there no mention of whether this had been a common practice at the mine, and whether it was known to management to be the case?  Why have procedural controls been put in place when commercial available, off the shelf engineering solutions exist for this problem?  Why are we placing so much reliance on people not making mistakes, when making mistakes is part of the human condition?

For more information, contact Mike Taylor or call 02 4924 5400.

Previous Post Next generation muffler reduces noise of mobile machines Next Post SAVE THE DATE | Introduction to Arena Simulation Training | 26-28 Sept 2018

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Latest News

  • Independent simulation consulting for warehouse and distribution centres
  • Hushpak now offering custom fabrication services
  • Understanding how your premises will operate with social distancing
  • Achieving sound performance through collaboration
  • The Advitech Group COVID-19 update

Archives

Articles by Company

Acubis Technologies

Advitech

Hushpak

Novecom

Simulation Modelling Services

Want to know more?

Sign up for the latest news from The Advitech Group

Sign up

Contact Info

The Advitech Group Head Office

Address 7 Riverside Drive, Mayfield West Newcastle, NSW 2304, Australia

Email mail@advitechgroup.com.au

Phone (02) 4924 5400

Request a callback

Services

  • STEM-Based Consulting
  • Smart Systems
  • Integrated Noise Management
  • Energy and Sustainability
  • Advanced Manufacturing

Sectors

  • Mining
  • Coal Preparation and Handling
  • Agriculture
  • Defence
  • Manufacturing
  • Infrastructure
  • Government Agencies
  • Policies
  • Privacy
Email
Facebook
LinkedIn

©  2018 The Advitech Group – Login